About Bankers Insurance

“Hometown friendly and multi-state strong” describes our focus of maintaining long-standing relationships with our clients and communities.

We focus on you, the client, and endeavor to be your trusted insurance adviser, providing the right fit for your insurance needs. Our commitment is to provide No Excuse Client Service. Having grown to the second largest private insurance agency in Virginia, we use our buying power to negotiate better rates with insurance providers. Through the years we developed specialty insurance programs in specific industries and offer them nationwide.

Applied Expertise

The insurance industry is continuously evolving. We specialize in simplifying the complex and providing tailored insurance solutions for our clients. We can ensure you enjoy broad coverage at the best price.

In our business model, we still assign an account manager to each client and provide their email address and a phone number that rings right on their desk. Bypass the entire front office! We guide our clients seamlessly through the insurance shopping experience.

Should the unfortunate happen, be confident. Be prepared.

Our History

An association of community banks formed Bankers Insurance in 1999. However, we trace the roots of our founding agencies all the way back to 1896. And though we are now Virginia’s second largest privately-owned independent insurance agency, we remain structured to provide local client support at each of our offices throughout Virginia and North Carolina. View all our locations.

Humble beginnings…

About Us, Caleb West Insurance Agency Historical Photo, original insurance office Newport News, VA
About Us, Bankers Insurance Historical Photo
About Us, Staunton Insurance Agency Historical Photo
About Us, W F McCaleb Office October 1961, one of our original offices

Core Values and Business Philosophy

The client comes first.

We deliver comprehensive, competitively priced insurance products through financially strong insurance companies to ensure our clients receive the best value. We provide value-added tools and services, local customer support, and dedicated account management. Holding ourselves to the highest ethical and professional standards, Bankers Insurance maintains a small agency feel while leveraging large agency resources.

Core Values

  • Display Integrity in every interaction
  • Exhibit Teamwork and Coordination
  • Value the Insights and Perspectives of Others
  • Contribute to an Enjoyable Work Environment
  • Demonstrate Care and Concern of Others
  • Possess Creativity and an Entrepreneurial Spirit

Vision

Flourish as an independent agency recognized as the insurance provider of choice and engaged in the communities we serve.

Mission

Protect the assets of our clients to ensure their financial well being.

Some Legal Stuff

Bankers Insurance, LLC operates under the following Doing Business As (DBA) names:

DBA Name Jurisdiction
BI Insurance Agency, LLC Arizona
BI Insurance Agency L.L.C. Illinois
BI Insurance Agency, LLC Minnesota
BI Insurance Agency L.L.C. Nevada
BI Insurance Agency New Hampshire
BI Insurance Agency L.L.C. New Hampshire
BI Insurance Agency L.L.C. New York
BI Insurance Agency L.L.C. Pennsylvania
BI Insurance Agency, LLC West Virginia